
Starting Wednesday, The California Supreme Court will hear arguments in the case of a lesbian mother against fertility doctors who refused to provide fertility treatments on religious grounds.
The lesbian, Guadalupe Benitez from Oceanside, north of San Diego, received 11 preliminary drug treatments in 2000 before being rejected from the actual in vitro component when the doctors at the clinic discovered her sexuality. She eventually, along with her partner, went to a private clinic, not covered by either one of their health insurance plans, and had a son (they now have two daughters as well).
According to KCBS, the women are suing under the state’s Unruh civil rights law, which protects gay men and lesbians from discrimination in the state. They claim that the doctors’ refusal at the North Coast Women’s Care Medical Group cost them thousands of dollars because they had to seek another doctor.
Lawyers for the clinic contend doctors have a right to accommodate their religious beliefs by referring a patient to a different doctor. The Supreme Court must decide whether the clinic’s lawyers can introduce a religious defense at the trial, which will take place in San Diego County Superior Court.
Benitez said in a previous interview, “People ask me, ‘Why are you doing this? You have your kids.’ I want to make a difference. These doctors are not God. They cannot manipulate who can have children and who cannot.”

Atty. Gen. Jerry Brown urges high court to let Prop. 8 take effect - Los Angeles Times
DHHS fixing laptops to bar security slip-ups - News & Observer





1 response so far ↓
1 Be Ashamed // Jun 3, 2008 at 5:26 pm
She should be ashamed to make this an issue. In the end, she was nicely referred to another doctor, got what she wanted. So what are the damages? Wow, I did not know that one would ever have to be forced to give someone services/treatment. If someone tells you thanks, but no thanks, just move on and find someone else. There are plenty of other doctors, as she found, that are willing to help you. I guess this will show doctors that it is best to just lie and say, “sorry, we have full schedule and cannot help you.” That way, no lawsuits. “These doctors are not God. They cannot manipulate who can have children and who cannot.” - well sure they can.. they have the know how and ability and you do not. Some other doctor played God and gave you what you wanted and your probably love them for that.
Leave a Comment